Protests planned as Chicago's school board considers adding more charter schools

January 21, 2014

(WBEZ/Linda Lutton)
Students and activists protest charter school expansion. Lizette Lopez, right, is a freshman at Prosser Career Academy, located across the street from a proposed Noble Street charter school.

Charter school opponents are gearing up for multiple protests—including an overnight vigil Tuesday sponsored by the Chicago Teachers Union—as Chicago’s school board considers adding more charter schools to its portfolio.

The board’s scheduled vote Wednesday on whether to add up to 17 more schools to the system comes just eight months after Chicago closed a historic 50 schools. Another 10 charter campuses already have permission to open in fall of 2014.

Charter protesters cite varying reasons for their opposition: some are union supporters, and most charters aren’t union.

Others, like Prosser Career Academy ninth-grader Lizette Lopez, think money and improvement efforts should be put into existing schools.  She spoke Monday from the site of one of the proposed charters, which is directly across the street from her high school.

“My school is a great school, and it would be even better if they actually started investing in it, instead of spending …on unnecessary schools in my community.  How does even making a new school even make sense?” she asked Monday afternoon at a protest organized by students and community groups, among them Citizens United for Quality Education.

Zerlina Smith is mad her tax dollars could go to politically connected landlords, who plan to rent space to charters.

“You raised my tax dollars—that’s what my property taxes are for, my neighborhood schools. Evidently they’re not going to OUR children’s neighborhood schools. They are going to Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s friends,” Smith said at the protest, which featured a few dozen youth, parents and members of Action Now.

And Darryl Truss of the group Raise Your Hand questioned why a church group with no experience running a school would be tapped to open a charter in Austin, where four schools were closed in Chicago’s massive school closure.

Behind the protesters, bulldozers rumbled through the Rubenstein Lumber site where Noble Street Charter Network is proposing to locate its 15th campus. (The board will consider a 16th Noble Street campus to be located temporarily in the Loop.) Protesters blasted the charter school network and CPS for moving ahead with demolition at the site even before the school board votes.

Dispute over “priority areas”

In May, CPS closed 50 schools on grounds of declining enrollment. But in a Request for Proposals issued in August, officials invited charter schools to submit proposals for new schools to help relieve longtime school overcrowding on the Northwest and Southwest sides. In the past, the district had prioritized charter schools locating in areas that lacked “quality” school options. Those were often areas where enrollment was declining as well.

The activists protesting Monday said based on the school board agenda and the charter schools’ proposals, they could find only two schools that fell within the wide swaths the district identified as priority areas.

The Noble Street campus to be located at 5321 W. Grand Ave., for instance, is technically about a half mile outside the priority-area boundaries identified on a map in the RFP.

But Noble Street spokeswoman Angela Montagna says her organization has always considered that site part of the Belmont-Cragin neighborhood, identified as overcrowded. Montagna said about 400 students from the neighborhood are enrolled at other Noble Street schools, showing “there’s demand there for a Noble education,” she said. Montagna also said construction on the site would stop if the board votes down the Noble campus, but she said in order to get a school up and running by the fall, demolition needed to begin. The school’s construction will be privately funded.

Noble Street high schools—where students apply and are selected by lottery—post strong ACT scores in the city, though officials admit about 35 percent of Noble students don’t make it to senior year. They transfer to other high schools or drop out before then.

Chicago Public Schools has been unclear about the actual number of charter schools the school board will consider Monday—saying as recently as last week the board would vote on 21 proposed schools. CPS spokesman Joel Hood now says the district received proposals from nine organizations hoping to open 22 campuses. He says four of the proposals were withdrawn by the operators. The district now counts 17 schools up for Wednesday’s vote, but five of them would service dropouts, a separate type of charter school.

Hood says by CPS’s count, five proposed campuses serve the prioritized Northwest and Southwest sides, including the Noble campus. He says ultimately it comes down to this: Who would argue with having another really high performing school in the neighborhood?

“This was never intended to solely be about priority areas,” says Hood. “If a really great school comes in and wants to locate in an area we don’t necessarily consider a priority, if it’s a really great school, we’re going to consider it.”

Normally by this time, district administrators would have made public which charter schools they think should be approved by the school board. But this year, for reasons it has not explained, the district is not making public its recommendations until the morning of the vote.

School districts in Illinois are required to consider charter proposals annually. Any denied charter can appeal to a state charter commission, which can overrule the district and order the school be opened.

Charter campuses to be considered by the school board Wednesday:

  • Be the Change Charter School (Location TBD in McKinley Park, serving grades K-2 in 2014, eventually serving 475 students grades K-8)

  • Chicago Education Partnership (“By the Hand”) (K-6 campus to be located at 400 N. Leamington in Austin, grades 7-8 to be located at 415 N. Laramie in Austin. Opening in 2015, serving grades K-1. Eventually serving 810 students in grades K-8).

  • Concept Schools--Horizon Science Academy- Chatham Charter School (8522 S. Lafayette in Chatham, serving grades K-8 in 2014, eventually serving 725 students K-12. This would be Concept Schools’ third campus in Chicago).

  • Concept Schools--Horizon Science Academy- Chicago Lawn Charter School (5401 S. Western in Gage Park, serving grades K-8 in 2014, eventually serving 725 students K-12. This would be Concept Schools’ fourth campus in Chicago).

  • Connected Futures Academies Options Charter Schools (five campuses, all TBD, each serving 165 re-enrolled drop-outs ages 15-21 in 2014).

  • Curtis Sharif STEM Academy Charter School 1 (location TBD but according to founder tentatively at 7939 S. Western in the Auburn Gresham neighborhood), serving grades K-5 in 2014, eventually serving 300 students grades K-8).

  • Curtis Sharif STEM Academy Charter School 2 (location TBD but according to founder, tentatively at 87th and Kedzie in the Ashburn neighborhood), serving grades K-5 in 2014, eventually serving 300 students grades K-8).

  • Curtis Sharif STEM Academy Charter School 3 (location TBD, serving grades K-5 in 2014, eventually serving 300 students grades K-8).

  • Curtis Sharif STEM Academy Charter School 4 (location TBD, serving grades K-5 in 2014, eventually serving 300 students grades K-8).

  • Great Lakes Academy Charter School (location TBD in South Shore (per hearings and proposal), serving grades 1-2 in 2014, eventually serving 576 students grades K-8).

  • Intrinsic Charter School 2 (temporarily located at 4540 W. Belmont in the Kilbourn Park neighborhood), eventually moving to a location TBD on the Northwest Side, opening fall 2015 with grade 9, eventually serving 959 students grades 7-12. This would be Intrinsic’s second charter school in Chicago).(Intrinsic initially proposed opening four campuses under this RFP; a spokesman for CPS says the group withdrew three of those applications).

  • Noble Street Charter School- ITW David Speer Campus (To be permanently located at 5321 W. Grand Ave. in Belmont-Cragin, serving grade 9 in 2014 and eventually serving 900 students in grades 9-12. This would be the 15th Noble Street campus in Chicago).

  • Noble Street Charter School- Noble Harkness Academy Campus (To be temporarily located at 17 N. State St. in the Loop, serving grade 9 in 2014 and eventually serving 900 students in grades 9-12. This would be the 16th Noble Street campus in Chicago. The network would be authorized to educate 13,875 students).

Linda Lutton is a WBEZ education reporter. Follow her @WBEZeducation.