California Challenges China In Rare Earths Mining

January 31, 2011

Ina Jaffe

The minerals known as 'rare earths' sound like something an alchemist would use to turn into gold. But the minerals are what make the modern world function. Rare earths are used in cell phones, hybrid cars, wind turbines and computers.

China mines most of these minerals, but it's been cutting back on exports. It's caused the price of rare earths to soar, which has once again made it profitable to reopen a long-shuttered mine in California.

Approaching the rim of the rare earths pit mine in the California desert, you expect to see something rare. But Scott Honin, the mine's environmental manager points to a wall of rock as boringly brown as the vast desert around it.

"Over the course of the next few weeks, we'll start mining the whole western wall of our open pit. And I, like a lot of my co-workers, here have been waiting for this for a long time," Honin says.

Nothing has been mined there for nearly a decade.

The property known as Mountain Pass was owned by oil companies — most recently Chevron. But after 50 years of operation, it was no longer cost effective to compete with the Chinese. There were also permit problems and environmental issues.

"It was probably a good thing that we were shut down," says Mark Smith, CEO of Molycorp Minerals, which bought the mine in 2008.

Smith said it allowed them to reevaluate the first 50 years of its operation. "Take a look at the strengths that we had, the weaknesses, try to re-strategize how we wanted to run this business and get it back on its feet," he said.

A Cleaner Operation

Smith said the first thing they decided on was to run a cleaner operation.

Mining rare earths is the easy part. The 17 elements that comprise rare earths are naturally found mixed together. And Smith says the usual method for separating the elements requires a witch's brew of chemicals: Sulfuric acid, hydrochloric acid, nitric acid, sodium hydroxide, sodium bicarbonate and ammonia.

The chemicals used to be trucked up to Mountain Pass in as many as 20 tankers a day, says Smith. The by-product of the separation process was 850 gallons of saltwater a minute, which was piped into evaporation ponds.

Now Molycorp has invented a method of taking that saltwater and reprocessing it back into the two main chemicals they use to separate the rare earths. It'll make the production cleaner and a lot cheaper.

The operators at this plant are separating the elements neodymium and praseodymium from lanthanum and cerium. Honin said they're getting the kinks out of the new process while a new plant is being built.

"So when we build the big plant we'll have an experienced group of operators and we'll have a really good understanding of the technology so that it will run very smoothly," Honin said.

Molycorp plans to open the new plant in 2012. They expect to produce as much as 40,000 tons a year. And that can't happen soon enough to suit Republican congressman Mike Coffman from Colorado.

Meeting U.S. Demand

Coffman is concerned about national security. He says rare earths are used in a lot of military equipment.

"Everything from night vision goggles, to fighter aircraft to precision-guided munitions," he says.

So Coffman is drafting legislation that he says will support the mining, processing and stockpiling of rare earths in the U.S.

"In case we have an extreme shortage of these metals to where we're not able to produce the kinds of weapons systems that we need for national security that are reliant upon these metals," Coffman said.

Ed Richardson, vice president of Thomas & Skinner Inc., a company makes magnets with military applications, has also pushed the government to stop depending on China for rare earths. He says the U.S. is in a global competition for rare earth minerals.

"The gap in terms of the world demand outside of what China has said they'll export is about 100,000 tons," Richardson says.

He said that as China's industry grows, its exports of rare earths will continue to shrink.

"They're going to use all the rare earths they mine and then some," said Richardson. "So, many in the industry think that [China] will eventually not export at all, that they will eventually import rare earths."

And if that happens, it means that one day China might not be Molycorp's competitor, but one of its customers. Copyright 2011 National Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.