Your NPR news source

Iran Spat Pits President Against Supreme Leader

SHARE Iran Spat Pits President Against Supreme Leader

Political turmoil seems to be the norm in Iran: Last year it was the reformist opposition taking to the streets challenging what they saw as the fraudulent re-election of President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. Now another political fissure has emerged within the conservative camp, threatening possible open conflict between Iran’s president and its supreme leader.

There are significant differences among conservatives in Iran over many issues, but right now the focus is on economic subsidies. The price of basics in Iran, like bread, electricity and gasoline, has been heavily subsidized for decades. But when Ahmahinejad ordered the removal of subsidies two weeks ago, the price of gasoline quadrupled and the price of bread tripled overnight.

What’s more, Ahmadinejad moved to seize the revenues that would have been used for subsidies for his own purposes. He has begun paying the poorest segments of Iranian society to help mitigate the pain of the price increases.

Some estimate the value of the revenues saved at $100 billion, says Abbas Milani, director of Iran studies at Stanford University.

“They are taking the equivalent of $100 billion out of the economy that helped subsidize peoples’ livelihood, and giving back a pittance,” he said. “They are giving back the equivalent of $40 per person.”

Conservatives in the Parliament wanted to control these funds, but Ahmadinejad quickly recognized their enormous political value, Milani said.

“Basically Ahmadinejad has created an enormous system of patronage for himself that he will use to either prolong his own stay in power or put one of his cronies in the presidency,” he said.

That’s not to speak of the powerful surge in inflation that is expected to hit Iran in the coming months.

Ahmadinejad’s move appears to be part of a wider plan to enhance the powers of his own presidency, at the expense of Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, says Muhammad Sahimi, who writes for the website Tehran Bureau.

“He wants to act independent from Ayatollah Khamenei and he wants to consolidate the power in the office of the president,” Sahimi said.

One example of this was Ahmadinejad’s recent firing of Foreign Minister Manouchehr Mottaki. Foreign policy has always been the jurisdiction of the supreme leader.

Mottaki was the supreme leader’s man, says Omid Memarian, who writes on Iranian affairs for the Inter Press Service. “He had the support of the Parliament, and also he had the support of the supreme leader,” he said. “I talked with different sources and Ahmadinejad dismissed the foreign minister without the approval of the supreme leader.”

Apparently in retaliation, the supreme leader’s camp recently resurrected charges of corruption and abuse of power against one of Ahmadinejad’s vice presidents and against his chief of staff.

In response, Ahmadinejad has become more openly critical of the power of the ayatollahs, a clever move, in Sahimi’s view.

“He realizes that the Iranian public is tired of the clerics,” he said. “So by being opposed to clerics and also talking about, for example, Iranian culture rather than Islamic culture, that invokes Iranian nationalism rather than Islam, he has tried to create and gather some support among some segments of the society. So that’s a shrewd tactic on his part.”

There is one area where the two conservative camps have maintained common purpose -- the repression of the opposition. In recent weeks, a well-known filmmaker has been jailed for six years just for planning a movie about the opposition. An economist has been imprisoned for questioning the accuracy of economic data released by the government. And earlier this week, two people were hanged in Evin prison, one an alleged spy for Israel.

All of this is an indication of just how uneasy Iran’s leaders continue to feel, Milani says. “I think they know full well what the population wants, how disgruntled the population are, how worried the people are about the economic situation,” he said.

This is likely to have a significant impact on the still somewhat hidden tensions between the president and the supreme leader, Memarian says.

“We have to see now how the supreme leader reacts to Ahmadinejad’s reckless policies,” he said. “Because at the end of the day, the supreme leader wants to survive. And if Ahmadinejad is endangering that kind of survival, then you know he has to go too, like many others.”

There is even talk of impeaching Ahmadinejad, but so far no serious move to carry out that threat. Copyright 2010 National Public Radio. To see more, visit


The Latest
It’s election day, and hundreds of teens are serving as election judges. The U.S. Supreme Court will hear arguments today in a case that could impact more than one million student people in Illinois with college debt. Local groups are stepping up to provide shelter for asylum seekers arriving in Chicago.