When A Transgender Person Uses A Public Bathroom, Who Is At Risk?
One issue at the center of North Carolina's so-called bathroom bill controversy is safety, but who's at risk? Depends on whom you ask.
Supporters of House Bill 2 tend to focus on people born male who later transition to female. The HB2 supporters say that without the new law, sexual predators could just say they're a transgender person with the right to use a women's bathroom and easily gain access to potential victims.
"He could be there to look at the anatomy of the opposite sex. He could be there because he's a sex pervert. He could be there to bring damage to a young girl," says Ron Baity, president of Return America and pastor at Berean Baptist Church in Winston-Salem, N.C.
Baity organized a rally at the state capitol last month to thank lawmakers and North Carolina Gov. Pat McCrory for making HB2 into law.
The legislation limits civil rights protections for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people, preventing local governments from extending rights beyond what the state offers.
The part of the law getting the most attention requires public institutions — including schools and government offices — to ensure that public restrooms be designated "male" and "female" and used by people based on their biological sex.
Baity and others with similar beliefs offer anecdotal evidence — crime reports — to support their claims.
But those cases involve sexual predators who put on women's clothes and violated any number of previously existing laws. And conflating "transgender" with "predator" is something many find offensive.
"As a trans person ... it's hard not to take it personally when people are comparing trans people to child predators or saying that we're somehow dangerous," says Alison Gill, vice chair of the Trans United Fund.
Gill points out that not long ago, many people incorrectly thought gay men were pedophiles.
She says some people just don't understand that when it comes time for a transgender person to start using the other restroom, they'd rather do it privately, and with as little fuss as possible.
"The last thing you as a trans person would want to do is draw attention to yourself," Gill says.
So far 17 states and many more communities across the United States include transgender people among protected classes for public accommodations.
Jody Herman is a public policy scholar at the UCLA School of Law's Williams Institute, a research group that focuses on sexual orientation and gender identity law and policy. The institute is working on a study to learn if extending public accommodations rights to transgender people leads to more crimes by predators.
Early indications are that it does not.
"As far as we know there hasn't been some sort of, you know, devolving into chaos in restrooms," Herman says.
One thing she can say for certain: Based on her survey of 93 transgender and gender non-conforming people in Washington, D.C., in 2008 and 2009, they themselves are at risk in restrooms.
"About 70 percent of the sample reported experiencing being denied access to restrooms, being harassed while using restrooms and even experiencing some forms of physical assault," says Herman.
Eight of the 93 respondents in her survey said they had been physically attacked in a restroom.