Your NPR news source

Do U.S. Ties To Egypt's Military Give It Leverage?

SHARE Do U.S. Ties To Egypt's Military Give It Leverage?

How Egypt’s military handles the thousands of protesters marching Tuesday through the streets of Cairo could decide the country’s future. The country’s military has for the past three decades received billions of dollars in U.S. aid and even sends its most promising officers to study in American war colleges. Yet for all that, it’s not at all clear whether the U.S. has leverage with Egypt’s military leadership.

When he ran the Army War College a decade ago, retired Maj. Gen. Robert Scales got to know the future leaders of the Egyptian military.

“The Egyptian military has been very careful to send only the best and the brightest and the most promising officers to American schools,” he said.

Today, most of the American military schools — from West Point to National Defense University in Washington — have an Egyptian officer sitting in the classroom. Right now, one is even on a class trip to San Francisco. Those relationships, Scales says, build what he calls enormous influence with Egypt.

“Not just because of the schools, but because of almost 30 years of intimate contact from exercises to the sale of military hardware like M1 tanks and F-16 fighter jets,” he said.

That’s hundreds of F-16s and plans for 1,200 M1 tanks as part of the more than $1 billion in U.S. military aid Egypt gets every year.

So it wasn’t unusual last week that the top Egyptian officer, Army Lt. Gen. Sami Enan, was in Washington for talks with his Pentagon friends. When Egypt descended into chaos, Enan cut his visit short. Later, the top U.S. officer, Adm. Mike Mullen, called the Egyptian general and pledged to continue the strong relationship between the two countries.

But Jon Alterman, who runs the Middle East program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, says that the Pentagon may be kidding itself if it thinks there’s a special bond.

“The Egyptians have been very careful not to allow tight relationships between the U.S. and Egyptian officers to develop, some would argue to prevent a pro-American coup in the military,” Alterman said.

There’s a history of coups: The military toppled the government a half century ago, and President Hosni Mubarak was an Air Force general.

In the face of mounting protests, Mubarak has tried to pull the military closer to him. He’s reshuffled his Cabinet and placed senior Egyptian generals in top positions.

Alterman says the U.S. can do little more than watch the unfolding revolt.

“I don’t think there’s anything the U.S. can do that’s really decisive in terms of what’s happening on the streets in Egypt or in terms of determining how the Egyptian government views what’s happening on the streets,” he said. “It seems to very much have its own momentum.”

That momentum has surprised the young Egyptian military officers in the classrooms at National Defense University, a short distance from the White House.

“They were watching with everybody the news and could not believe what was going on and how fast it went,” said Gawdat Bahgat, an Egyptian who teaches national security at the university.

He says the class of international officers spent an hour talking about events in Egypt, but the Egyptian officers had little to say and echoed the government line.

“They work for the government and they see it from the government’s perspective so to some extent I understand,” he said.

Alterman says what’s unknown is what role these and other younger officers will play in the growing crisis.

“The 1952 coup was made by colonels and we have no idea where the colonels are in any of this,” he said.

So far, Alterman says, the colonels haven’t had to make a choice. Copyright 2011 National Public Radio. To see more, visit

The Latest
It’s election day, and hundreds of teens are serving as election judges. The U.S. Supreme Court will hear arguments today in a case that could impact more than one million student people in Illinois with college debt. Local groups are stepping up to provide shelter for asylum seekers arriving in Chicago.