Replacements to blow the whistle for the NFL

Replacements to blow the whistle for the NFL

The Chicago Bears will see some unfamiliar faces on the field when the season starts Sunday, September 9th. That’s becasue the labor strife between the National Football League and its referees will continue into the regular season. In a memo sent to all 32 NFL teams by the league’s executive vice president for football operations, the NFL warned that replacement refs will be used in the first week of the 2012 season.

The NFL has been using replacement refs in pre-season games and training camps, with regular refs locked-out. The league believes they have sufficiently trained these replacement officials in such a way as to let them move forward without the regular referees:

Replacement referees will continue into the regular NFL season. (AP Photo/Alan Diaz)

The replacements have undergone extensive training and evaluation, and have shown steady improvement during the preseason. We will continue the training with each crew and they will work as much of the regular season as necessary. The replacement officials are dedicated and enthusiastic, have worked very hard to improve, and have persevered despite the attacks on their qualifications and performance. We are all grateful for their service to the NFL.

The players, coaches and staff of all the NFL teams have been instructed to not talk about the dispute, but that hasn’t stopped everyone from speaking out against the temporary refs. And with safety in mind, the players union is now contemplating some action. NFL Players Association (NFLPA) executive director DeMaurice Smith voiced his concerns in an interview with the day before the memo came out:

Obviously the game is going to speed up, the demand on the referees increase, the physical strain on our players’ increases exponentially, and you’re facing a situation where the league has made an affirmative decision to remove the people that we consider to be the first responders to safety on the field. It’s rather obvious that the only people on the field who are not competing, who remain objective to enforce the rules, to ensure that the players remain safe, are the referees.

Jerry Markbreit, a former NFL Referee with 35 years of experience and 23 in the league, said safety is a huge concern for him. He was employed by the league to train referees — until the lock-out. Markbreit said he and nine others in the same position “have been fired” since they didn’t want to cooperate by training “scabs.”

The replacement refs, Markbreit said, “will not be able to recognize and control the game.” Watching the pre-season games he said he saw several penalties missed — hits on quarterbacks and helmets to chests. “I saw a quarterback tackled around the neck and slammed to the ground,” he said. Markbreit doesn’t believe the replacements referees will be able to control players who want to take advantage of the situation once the regular season gets underway; the pre-season, he said, is much less intense than what we’ll see next Wednesday when the NFL kicks off the year.

Former NFL referee Jerry Markbreit is concerned about players' safety with replacement refs. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
Markbreit is also miffed that the league hasn’t had a negotiating session since July 27th. “You think the league would be willing to negotiate, but they really are not willing to sit down and change their original offer.” Markbreit said issues under discussion include pensions, salary, adding additional referees and making a small group of referees full-time. The NFL said in its memo that “officials continue to insist on larger overall pay increases, as well as greater amounts devoted for non-game compensation, than we consider reasonable in light of economic developments of recent years and compensation trends for other leagues and team employees.”

The union looks at the addition of 20 rookie referees as a quick way to dilute quality and the shared earnings of 120 present members. The league says they want to inject more officials into the league and give more rest to some crews, as well as the ability to replace refs. “One of our key goals in this negotiation is to enhance our ability to recruit, train, and replace officials who are not performing adequately,” the league said.

But the issue of pensions seems to be a real sticking point, with the NFL wanting to freeze and eventually end the present plan for one that is contribution-based.

The perception that NFL refs only work three hours every week for 20 weeks is erroneous in Markbreit’s eyes. “This is a full-time job for seven months of the year masquerading as a part time job,” he said. The referees go to clinics and training camps, view videos, take exams and spend a lot of time on the phone. “It takes over your life,” said Markbreit.

The player’s union can threaten to side with the regular referees and honor the picket line. That seems unlikely since it would be hard for them to give up their hefty pay checks. It is a matter of wait and see, but for Jerry Markbreit the situation is quite upsetting. “It’s a crying shame that the league is taking this stance,” he said. “It is just not right.”

For now, the ball is, so to speak, in the NFL’s hands.